Determining what is 'right' is a longwinded question with no real answer at all. But there are guidelines: taking responsibility for one's actions, telling the truth, treating people with mutual respect and dignity, standing up for yourself and/or others, injustice, fairness, whatever. But what does any of this matter here in a Western society that no longer values this within ourselves?
We no longer hold these things dear. It used to be that a 'man' was only as good as his 'word' and that honesty meant something. It was all he had. Now certainly it would be nice to expand that to 'person', as opposed to just a 'man', but the fact of the matter is that it just doesn't mean that much anymore to anyone. People focus on themselves first, foremost, and even solely; they will compromise what is 'right' in a second if it means that they individually might have to sacrifice. Would you stand up for what you believe to be 'right' even if it means it might cause you some discomfort or loss? To what extent?
You live in a small town, you know people there, they know you. An employer you know well decides not to pay their employee for some hours worked and your testimony could provide justice in the situation. No lies or anything of the sort needed, simply telling the truth if asked. Yet that is too much to ask even as the person not getting paid is someone you have loved. You know they worked there, you know they put in the effort, and you know they have accepted responsibility for their own personal indiscretions. They simply want to be paid for their time worked. Yet you do not stand up for them or for honesty or integrity in general but rather simply for your own self-interest. A self-interest that in-fact promotes dishonesty elsewhere. And we as a society not only understand that, we condone it, we make it so that this choice is acceptable and perhaps necessary. This is the most shameful part - this is way life has become us.
Our world has become about nothing more than individual politicking. We play both sides, we do what we must do to raise ourselves up the ladders of life whether through the course of integrity or not. Value judgements are placed on when and where we use our concept of integrity. There are no principles, no stands to be made for what is 'right' or 'wrong', no real care about others or concessions to our selves or our 'individual liberties' in the face of another's. The only stand that we make is that singularly popular stand for ourselves - even if this happens in the face of compromising ours or someone else's integrity. This is truly a sad world we've created, and it is a world that - with each stand we do not take - that we continually perpetuate each and every day... :(
Showing posts with label The Individual. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Individual. Show all posts
Monday, July 19, 2010
Monday, November 9, 2009
Personal Wars
Amazing to read and discuss about this situation with the shooting at Fort Hood in Texas. General American sentiment seems to dismiss the reality of how difficult it must be to be a Muslim in the US army today. Statements of the prejudicial treatment he received – keyed car, 'camel jockey get out', diapers in his car with claims it should be his headdress? This is a man that decided to go into the military – for whatever reasons – and should have been afforded the respect of that commitment. It also needs to be said that he committed at a time when the military didn't seem so solely focused on issues that could be seen to fall on religious or ideological lines as could be seen today.
These wars, and American society as a whole, have been and are showing Islam as a culprit – as these prejudicial acts show. There are people that viewed his religious situation as a problem, and this I believe is where the problem comes from. If the military was more 'open minded' (yes, I did just say that), perhaps a Muslim man would have felt more welcome in this institution. But the military doesn't care about individuals or their religion, sexual preference, etc. It just wants to create soldiers willing to do what the country's leaders deem to be necessary. Yet this inflexibility and the cultural hostility that is growing in America made a well qualified man feel uncomfortable enough to lash out and kill. And all the official statements can be made that anyone wants, but we should all know full well that the military is stretched, looking for numbers, and was not going to be trying to release a Arab-American psychiatrist at a time like today, or that the people he spoke to from within this military would even pretend to be sympathetic to his concerns. The bottom line is they don't care, and they are taught not to care – An Army of One.
The fact of the matter is that today we have another front on the war-on-terror opening up. This man was a part of 'us', part of America, yet he was pushed out and ended up 'fighting' in virtual cohesion with the 'other side'. And the victims, the dead soldiers, are not any different than others from the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, they are casualties of this war. People need to recognize that these wars are bigger than tanks and troops on the ground, and each person in the world fights their part of it every day. It is about ideology and culture – both of which are wholly individual and subjective – and our individual actions to every person we see. In provoking an attack like this through verbal provocation or subtle antagonizing messages we are fighting a battle. Which side do your actions place you on? Do you need to be on a side?
There are no cookie cutters and no past victories to learn from in this type of warfare. In a world where the individual is solely taught to focus on themselves, yet while the system simultaneously tries to thoroughly group and categorize us all away, it is very difficult to factor in individuals and their variances. This man was a person with ideas, beliefs, and issues to be heard. Yet no one was listening with any intent on truly helping or including him and/or his concerns into the system. This type of front has been around forever yet seems to never be realized by people. It must be fought by us all, all the time. The key to it is to realize just as any war, their will be both attacks and retaliations, and their will be casualties. Enough individuals fired insults, and enough institutional rigidities and insensitivities where thrown around that a retaliation was made – and one that cost people their lives. The person that keyed his car, the diaper person, the camel jockey person, are wholly responsible by being the ones that fired the first shots, thus causing this man's retaliated. So lets think about where we stand in this 'war' every time we open our mouths. Do you want to fight for one 'side' or the other, or do you want to be a conscientious objector and/or peacemaker?
For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. And despite what we were taught as kids, while sticks and stones may break bones, words can break PEOPLE... and there is no retaliation proportional or equivalent to this type of damage – a broken wo/man has no limits as to what they are capable of. So think, every time you say something, A, will I break something, and B, am I ready for the retaliation if something does break?
These wars, and American society as a whole, have been and are showing Islam as a culprit – as these prejudicial acts show. There are people that viewed his religious situation as a problem, and this I believe is where the problem comes from. If the military was more 'open minded' (yes, I did just say that), perhaps a Muslim man would have felt more welcome in this institution. But the military doesn't care about individuals or their religion, sexual preference, etc. It just wants to create soldiers willing to do what the country's leaders deem to be necessary. Yet this inflexibility and the cultural hostility that is growing in America made a well qualified man feel uncomfortable enough to lash out and kill. And all the official statements can be made that anyone wants, but we should all know full well that the military is stretched, looking for numbers, and was not going to be trying to release a Arab-American psychiatrist at a time like today, or that the people he spoke to from within this military would even pretend to be sympathetic to his concerns. The bottom line is they don't care, and they are taught not to care – An Army of One.
The fact of the matter is that today we have another front on the war-on-terror opening up. This man was a part of 'us', part of America, yet he was pushed out and ended up 'fighting' in virtual cohesion with the 'other side'. And the victims, the dead soldiers, are not any different than others from the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, they are casualties of this war. People need to recognize that these wars are bigger than tanks and troops on the ground, and each person in the world fights their part of it every day. It is about ideology and culture – both of which are wholly individual and subjective – and our individual actions to every person we see. In provoking an attack like this through verbal provocation or subtle antagonizing messages we are fighting a battle. Which side do your actions place you on? Do you need to be on a side?
There are no cookie cutters and no past victories to learn from in this type of warfare. In a world where the individual is solely taught to focus on themselves, yet while the system simultaneously tries to thoroughly group and categorize us all away, it is very difficult to factor in individuals and their variances. This man was a person with ideas, beliefs, and issues to be heard. Yet no one was listening with any intent on truly helping or including him and/or his concerns into the system. This type of front has been around forever yet seems to never be realized by people. It must be fought by us all, all the time. The key to it is to realize just as any war, their will be both attacks and retaliations, and their will be casualties. Enough individuals fired insults, and enough institutional rigidities and insensitivities where thrown around that a retaliation was made – and one that cost people their lives. The person that keyed his car, the diaper person, the camel jockey person, are wholly responsible by being the ones that fired the first shots, thus causing this man's retaliated. So lets think about where we stand in this 'war' every time we open our mouths. Do you want to fight for one 'side' or the other, or do you want to be a conscientious objector and/or peacemaker?
For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. And despite what we were taught as kids, while sticks and stones may break bones, words can break PEOPLE... and there is no retaliation proportional or equivalent to this type of damage – a broken wo/man has no limits as to what they are capable of. So think, every time you say something, A, will I break something, and B, am I ready for the retaliation if something does break?
Labels:
Afghanistan,
American Culture,
Culture,
Fort Hood,
Iraq,
Military,
Muslim,
Society,
The Individual,
War
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
Groupthink
Which comes first, the individual or the group? What makes which? Does the individual make the group or the group make the individual? This seems like a pretty simple answer to me. Beyond just the basic logic that multiple actors are usually more powerful than one single actor, it still is worth discussing given today's focus on the individual as primary. First and foremost, groups have history, and society – as a group – is THE history (not referring to the written record of it, but all of it as it existed and became today). An individual is born one day and does not exist prior to that moment. Yet in examining society we mostly break a study of it down to the individual, reducing our frame of reference to singular actors and their interaction within the group. But these actors do not exist in a vacuum, they exist in social and physical settings that existed long before them as individuals and will remain to exist long after them. Individuals, as we like to believe them to be, do not exist as such. The are formed by and largely reducible to the group with which they identify with.
Obviously there is an argument for which came first, the individual or the group. It would be simple to say the individual was first and then they came to be in groups as they expanded. A christian type religious view could support this. Yet an evolutionary view would look at the slow evolution of entities into conscious beings that found themselves acting in groups. Honestly, I don't see the point of this type of debate, who's basic point is trying to figure out how or why we are here – or what will happen upon the end of our time here. I find it far more productive to focus upon now. The time that we can see and act both upon and within. So my point is that society exists prior to the individual. Individual's can act upon groups, but individuals gain the ability and methods of action through socializing in groups, and thus are beholden to groups.
This being said, what does this mean about/for us as humans? If we understand that we basically live in both groups, and one immense group, then it is in fact these groups that we must change – not the individuals within these groups – for the individuals will then change upon variations from within the group. It is the system, the group, that creates and molds us that must be looked at and changed. We are all but products of this system and our moment in time.
Obviously there is an argument for which came first, the individual or the group. It would be simple to say the individual was first and then they came to be in groups as they expanded. A christian type religious view could support this. Yet an evolutionary view would look at the slow evolution of entities into conscious beings that found themselves acting in groups. Honestly, I don't see the point of this type of debate, who's basic point is trying to figure out how or why we are here – or what will happen upon the end of our time here. I find it far more productive to focus upon now. The time that we can see and act both upon and within. So my point is that society exists prior to the individual. Individual's can act upon groups, but individuals gain the ability and methods of action through socializing in groups, and thus are beholden to groups.
This being said, what does this mean about/for us as humans? If we understand that we basically live in both groups, and one immense group, then it is in fact these groups that we must change – not the individuals within these groups – for the individuals will then change upon variations from within the group. It is the system, the group, that creates and molds us that must be looked at and changed. We are all but products of this system and our moment in time.
Thursday, July 2, 2009
The Soul as Competitor
Competition is an interesting and often unchallenged foundation of western society. In America it is the unfettered absolute of social interaction – espoused as the way to move and motivate individuals to make themselves better, and to provide society with social and economic growth. In Europe it seems to take a softer tone, finding verbiage in business and ‘right-of-center’ political circles, and has only been a part of the vanguard since the privatizing 80’s. I myself – having been raised stoutly within an ultra-competitive athletics atmosphere – was once called ‘the most competitive person’ my coach had ever seen (and he’d coached several world class athletes). This motivation has begotten me a great deal of what I am in life, yet today I find myself at war within myself over this drive and determination. After all, competition by another name is the drive to be better or best – the unquenchable thirst for self satisfaction in relation to others; or better termed as the drive to make someone, or everyone, worse than you – inferior to yourself. Do I really want everyone else to be worse than me?
Society today rewards the ‘winners’ and puts more pressure on the ‘losers’ (See the movie Bigger Stronger Faster), as our present day society – capitalist society – is at its core based solely on the ‘individual’ as the primary actor and motivator. But this motivating force in-turn puts the individual at odds with their surroundings and all others inhabiting them. Competition has innocuously seeped into all realms of society. It starts to get indoctrinated into us as culture with youth sports and gold stars in school classrooms, then with placement in schools, athletics, and status groups; upon which it is finally realized in the jobs, material items, and money of our adulthood. Capitalist society is based upon this competition between wage-laborers, and it relies upon the reserve (unemployed) labor pool to always have another person to fill your post unless you are ‘better’ than them (or they are ‘worse’ than you).
Most people in Anglo-American society are ok with the above concept; after all, if you work hard you can achieve anything, right? But look at the world around us. And no, not just the one outside your country’s borders (often personified as being lead by 'barbarians, heathens, and other distasteful interlopers') but the one within our borders. The poor, the disparate, the crime, gang violence, school shootings… the list goes on for days. Western society is not healthy, and it is tough to justify promoting a sickly model to other parts of the world especially while selling it off as idyllic. The current system is not fundamentally based upon ‘success’, but upon competing amongst our selves, our groups, and our countries – competition that easily turns conflictual, and is never ‘successful’.
Put two individuals (solely focused on themselves) into a vacuum with one plate of food, and they will compete over said plate as within this scenario it is their sole motive to think of their own self and survival. If their mindsets are night and day, self versus group, they will come into conflict as it is me v. you. Only within a cooperatively motivated environment can this situation not actually come to conflict, as the option to share would now be a possibility as they could think about more than themselves. You may of course then say, yes but we don’t live in a vacuum there are so many other societal factors that come into play: altruism, compassion, charity, even negotiation and compromise. Of course, but if at our core – in our soul – our intrinsic motivations focus on the self, opening the door for conflict, then it is a paramount need for society to counteract this competition and subsequent conflict. This is specifically why it is of the utmost importance to create/live in a society that minimizes these singular self motivations. This is not to say that human nature is negative or ‘evil’, but that as we see society today it leads to competitive conflict (if man is a ‘social being’ then it is in his/her nature to compromise the space around themselves in order to share it with others). To create a systemic social, economic, and cultural setting that decreases the chances of competition, thus decreasing conflict, should be our goal – not to expand the institutionalization of individualized competitive scenarios that pervade Western society to other areas of the world.
Think of it like this: today’s society idolizes selfless acts (‘taking one for the team’, taking the bullet for another, accepting responsibility for another’s failure, etc.), yet at the same time society does not ‘set itself up’ to actually facilitate or reproduce these acts, never mind to truly or tangibly reward them, either literally or from within its systemic infrastructure. Singular rewards chosen from 6.5 billion people like the Nobel peace prize are not given to the ‘average’ person. ‘Regular’ people don’t think about this award past a fleeting glance, never mind receive it, and the selfless person that takes individual responsibility for a group’s failure is often ‘fired’ from their job. It is sad, but despite the rhetoric, the ideals and principles of ‘the self-less wo/man’ are but festering and decayed road kill resting under capitalism’s bus…
We can do better.
Society today rewards the ‘winners’ and puts more pressure on the ‘losers’ (See the movie Bigger Stronger Faster), as our present day society – capitalist society – is at its core based solely on the ‘individual’ as the primary actor and motivator. But this motivating force in-turn puts the individual at odds with their surroundings and all others inhabiting them. Competition has innocuously seeped into all realms of society. It starts to get indoctrinated into us as culture with youth sports and gold stars in school classrooms, then with placement in schools, athletics, and status groups; upon which it is finally realized in the jobs, material items, and money of our adulthood. Capitalist society is based upon this competition between wage-laborers, and it relies upon the reserve (unemployed) labor pool to always have another person to fill your post unless you are ‘better’ than them (or they are ‘worse’ than you).
Most people in Anglo-American society are ok with the above concept; after all, if you work hard you can achieve anything, right? But look at the world around us. And no, not just the one outside your country’s borders (often personified as being lead by 'barbarians, heathens, and other distasteful interlopers') but the one within our borders. The poor, the disparate, the crime, gang violence, school shootings… the list goes on for days. Western society is not healthy, and it is tough to justify promoting a sickly model to other parts of the world especially while selling it off as idyllic. The current system is not fundamentally based upon ‘success’, but upon competing amongst our selves, our groups, and our countries – competition that easily turns conflictual, and is never ‘successful’.
Put two individuals (solely focused on themselves) into a vacuum with one plate of food, and they will compete over said plate as within this scenario it is their sole motive to think of their own self and survival. If their mindsets are night and day, self versus group, they will come into conflict as it is me v. you. Only within a cooperatively motivated environment can this situation not actually come to conflict, as the option to share would now be a possibility as they could think about more than themselves. You may of course then say, yes but we don’t live in a vacuum there are so many other societal factors that come into play: altruism, compassion, charity, even negotiation and compromise. Of course, but if at our core – in our soul – our intrinsic motivations focus on the self, opening the door for conflict, then it is a paramount need for society to counteract this competition and subsequent conflict. This is specifically why it is of the utmost importance to create/live in a society that minimizes these singular self motivations. This is not to say that human nature is negative or ‘evil’, but that as we see society today it leads to competitive conflict (if man is a ‘social being’ then it is in his/her nature to compromise the space around themselves in order to share it with others). To create a systemic social, economic, and cultural setting that decreases the chances of competition, thus decreasing conflict, should be our goal – not to expand the institutionalization of individualized competitive scenarios that pervade Western society to other areas of the world.
Think of it like this: today’s society idolizes selfless acts (‘taking one for the team’, taking the bullet for another, accepting responsibility for another’s failure, etc.), yet at the same time society does not ‘set itself up’ to actually facilitate or reproduce these acts, never mind to truly or tangibly reward them, either literally or from within its systemic infrastructure. Singular rewards chosen from 6.5 billion people like the Nobel peace prize are not given to the ‘average’ person. ‘Regular’ people don’t think about this award past a fleeting glance, never mind receive it, and the selfless person that takes individual responsibility for a group’s failure is often ‘fired’ from their job. It is sad, but despite the rhetoric, the ideals and principles of ‘the self-less wo/man’ are but festering and decayed road kill resting under capitalism’s bus…
We can do better.
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
An Analogy of Today’s Individual
An Individual’s ability to make their own decisions rests on their social existence. Their upbringing, their life experiences, those surrounding them, etc. A good analogy for this is to think of American football. Take one great player on a team full of average players. No I am not going to talk about how the team is only as good as its weakest link, or one great player doesn’t make a team – though this concept of team is important to keep in mind. The thing that I want to elucidate is that this one player may be great or may not be great depending upon their utilization within the ‘system’. If the ‘system’ was of no importance, then why would there be offensive and defensive playbooks or coaches? It is the system that can bring a player’s skills to light. A good receiver on a team that runs the ball 75% of the time may never be seen as a great player unless the offensive system accentuates that individual’s skill set – thus they are beholden to the system they play in. Its easy to say in football that they can go play for another team, yet in the team game that is life, we can’t just decide to go play somewhere else, we are in this game and this offensive system whether we like it or not.
The problem that we face today is that the social system we are in produces societal ‘players’ solely focused on themselves. We are taught about individual freedoms, personal choice, individual rights, private property, etc. All of these are valuable and admirable things, but on the whole, self-based motives and actions – Me. Mine. Ours.
So how does a self-obsessed player like this translate to the analogous football field? They are the ‘pre-madonna’ wide receivers that whine when they don’t ‘get the damn ball’. We all know them and we love watching them make plays, but then chastise them for what they say and do otherwise. Imagine a football team with nothing but flashy pre-madonna wide receivers at every position? That is what our world is turning into. Some of us have been on those teams, even been those players, but that is not what makes successful team chemistry. Why then should we pretend that what doesn’t work in the most obvious team sports we’ve seen will work in the largest and most indefinable team sport we play – life?
The problem that we face today is that the social system we are in produces societal ‘players’ solely focused on themselves. We are taught about individual freedoms, personal choice, individual rights, private property, etc. All of these are valuable and admirable things, but on the whole, self-based motives and actions – Me. Mine. Ours.
So how does a self-obsessed player like this translate to the analogous football field? They are the ‘pre-madonna’ wide receivers that whine when they don’t ‘get the damn ball’. We all know them and we love watching them make plays, but then chastise them for what they say and do otherwise. Imagine a football team with nothing but flashy pre-madonna wide receivers at every position? That is what our world is turning into. Some of us have been on those teams, even been those players, but that is not what makes successful team chemistry. Why then should we pretend that what doesn’t work in the most obvious team sports we’ve seen will work in the largest and most indefinable team sport we play – life?
Labels:
American Culture,
Culture,
Football,
Individualism,
Society,
Sports,
The Individual
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)